S Deatherage Law

Practice Areas

EV Charging

Electric vehicle charging infrastructure: siting and leasing, utility interconnection, permitting, construction and procurement, incentives and grants, and the environmental credits that charging may generate.

In brief: Scott co-founded an electric vehicle charging company and served as its Chief Legal Officer from formation to its sale to a private equity firm. His experience included siting and leasing, utility interconnection, charging regulation, procurement and construction, incentives and environmental credits, financing, and disputes, among other areas of law.

Scott co-founded an EV charging infrastructure company with five other people and served as its Chief Legal Officer from 2018 to 2026. He built the legal function from formation through growth, supported by one other attorney and by outside counsel when specialized advice was needed.

The work of a charging company's legal department

The role covered the whole of the company's legal needs, from formation through financing, development, operations, and disputes.

  • Advising the chief executive and the board on strategy, risk, and governance, and establishing the company's corporate governance and policies
  • Negotiating the company's initial private equity investment, and supporting a later sale of the company to a second private equity firm
  • An application for a United States Department of Energy loan, prepared with outside counsel, which received phase one approval of a $225 million loan
  • Ground leases, site access agreements, and purchases and sales of real property for charging station deployments, together with a sale leaseback of company-owned property
  • Standard forms for nondisclosure agreements, master services agreements, vendor agreements, and ground leases
  • Document automation for certain contracts, including simple vendor agreements, which allowed business staff to answer a list of questions that generated an agreement for use with a vendor, without lawyer involvement where the vendor accepted it without negotiation
  • Procurement of solar panels, energy storage, transformers, switchgear, chargers, and charging cabinets
  • Engineering, architect, and construction agreements, including negotiation of AIA construction form contracts
  • Utility interconnection regulations and requirements, and interconnection agreements
  • A privacy program for customer information, including compliance with the California Consumer Privacy Act
  • An insurance program, including general liability, directors and officers, cyber security, and builder's risk
  • Pre-litigation matters and settlements, including a trademark dispute with a multibillion-dollar automobile manufacturer, a dispute with a battery supplier over testing and certification, and a dispute with an energy management technology company
  • Management of outside counsel in legal areas such as litigation, intellectual property, labor and employment, tax, and privacy

Siting, real property, and permitting

Scott has experience in the siting, purchasing, and leasing of property for construction of EV charging stations. The types of contracts and work include the following.

  • Environmental due diligence, including environmental consulting agreements and review of Phase I and Phase II Environmental Site Assessment reports
  • Review and management of potential vapor intrusion issues, including review of regulations and environmental consultant reports and negotiation of contracts for installing vapor barriers
  • Ground leases, easements, and license and site access agreements
  • Site host agreements, including revenue share, minimum guarantee, and charging as a service arrangements
  • Purchase and sale agreements, options, and sale leaseback structures
  • Title, access, parking, and exclusivity questions that may affect whether a site can be built or later relocated
  • City entitlement and local permitting, including the California statute requiring local agencies to expedite review of EV charging permits

Interconnection and electricity regulation

A direct current fast charging station demands a great deal of electricity, often in the many megawatt hours. A variety of legal issues and contracts arise in the development of EV charging stations.

  • Interconnection applications and interconnection agreements with utilities
  • Service upgrades, make-ready arrangements, and cost allocation between the utility and the developer
  • Rate schedules, demand charges, and the tariff terms that may govern what a charging site pays for power
  • Behind-the-meter solar and energy storage installed to reduce demand charges or to reduce the cost of electricity
  • Power purchase and supply arrangements
  • Electricity and utility regulatory analysis

Charging regulation and compliance

Scott has substantial experience in EV charging regulation in California, which has a robust EV charging statutory and regulatory program. Requirements may reach the equipment, the pricing, the payment methods, the data reported, and the accessibility of the site, and they continue to change. That experience extends to such regulation in Texas and other states, as well as to federal regulations.

  • Charging statutes and regulations applicable to a given site, network, or business model
  • Pricing disclosure, payment access, metering, and consumer protection requirements
  • Data collection, reporting, and privacy obligations attached to charging networks and customer accounts
  • Uptime, maintenance, and reporting commitments, which may arise by regulation, by grant condition, or by contract

Incentives, grants, and tax credits

Charging projects have been built on a mix of public money and credit markets, and the terms that come with the money are often the part that matters. A grant may carry wage, domestic content, uptime, reporting, and audit conditions that run for years after the site is energized.

  • Investment tax credits for solar and energy storage installed at charging sites
  • The federal credit for alternative fuel vehicle refueling property under section 30C of the Internal Revenue Code, which Congress terminated for property placed in service after June 30, 2026
  • Federal formula funding administered by the states, including the National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure program, and the award, subrecipient, and compliance terms that accompany it
  • State and utility incentive and make-ready programs, and the agreements under which they are paid
  • Grant compliance, including prevailing wage, domestic content, uptime, reporting, and recapture exposure

Environmental credits generated by charging

Electricity delivered to a vehicle may generate tradable environmental credits, and for some sites those credits are a meaningful part of the revenue, particularly in California. Who is entitled to them is sometimes not obvious, because the site host, the charger owner, the network operator, and the utility may each have a claim, and the answer may depend on the specific agreements or on state law.

  • California Low Carbon Fuel Standard credits, which may be generated both on the energy dispensed and, for qualifying fast charging infrastructure, on installed capacity
  • Registration, metering, quarterly reporting, and verification obligations, and the records a site must keep in order to claim credits at all
  • Allocation of credit rights and credit revenue among the site host, charger owner, network, and utility, and the indemnities that follow if a claim is later disallowed
  • Voluntary carbon credits associated with charging, including the question of what may be credited without double counting electricity attributes already sold as renewable energy credits
  • Renewable identification numbers under the federal Renewable Fuel Standard, including the effect of the Environmental Protection Agency's 2026 determination that renewable electricity does not qualify as a renewable fuel

Commercial agreements

The contract set for a charging business is wider than it first appears, and much of it is recurring work that benefits from standard forms and a settled negotiating position rather than from drafting each agreement again.

  • Master services agreements, software and technology licensing, and software as a service agreements
  • Supply, procurement, and distribution agreements for chargers, batteries, and electrical equipment
  • Engineering, procurement, and construction contracts, and operations and maintenance agreements
  • Fleet and commercial customer agreements, including depot charging for fleets
  • Warranty, testing, and certification terms, which have been the source of real disputes where equipment arrived without the certifications the contract assumed

Related practice areas

Charging work overlaps with the firm's energy and environmental practices, and the same questions of power, land, and permitting arise in data center and renewable project work. See Energy, Environmental, Business, and Industries.

Questions clients ask

Who owns the environmental credits that a charging site generates?

Whoever the agreements say owns them. Low carbon fuel credits and similar instruments are usually claimed by one registered party, and the site host, the charger owner, the network operator, and in some cases the utility may each expect to be that party. Where the contract is silent, the dispute tends to surface after the credits have value. It is worth settling in the lease or site host agreement, together with who carries the reporting and verification burden and what happens if a claim is later disallowed.

What should a landowner or site host look for in a charging agreement?

The term and renewal structure, what the operator may build and later replace, who pays for the electrical service and the upgrades, who holds the environmental credits, what happens to the equipment at the end of the term, and whether the operator may assign the agreement to someone the landowner has never met.

How long does it take to get a charging site energized?

Usually longer than the construction itself, and the utility interconnection is generally the critical path rather than the local permit. Capacity may not be available at the site, the service upgrade may be scheduled months out, and the equipment lead times may not align with either. A site should be evaluated for available capacity before the lease is signed rather than after.

Does the firm represent site hosts and landowners as well as charging companies?

Yes. The firm represents charging developers and operators, landowners and site hosts, fleet operators, and investors.

Does a charging operator become a regulated utility by selling electricity?

Generally not, but the answer is a matter of state law and is not uniform. Several states have addressed by statute or by commission order whether a person who resells electricity for vehicle charging is a public utility for that reason, and the treatment may differ for a public site, a fleet depot, and a site behind a host's meter. The question should be answered for the state in which the site is to be located before the business model is fixed.